There is a marked decline in charitable giving among the general population. While this has been offset in dollar terms by steadily larger gifts from wealthy benefactors, the troubling fact remains: The share of American households that donate to charity has been steadily declining since the Great Recession of 2008.

More than a third of the decline in giving participation can be attributed to changes in income and wealth. In any event, giving rates have decreased among both younger and older Americans, according to an Indiana University Lilly Family School of Philanthropy report released last year (opens as a pdf). Moreover, both charitable trust and overall giving participation are shrinking at a greater rate among younger Americans than among older Americans. 

There are a number of factors for the marginalization of giving, such as shifting demographics. New generations demand a different kind of interaction with the cause. 

• Have you framed your ask in a way that resonates with me?
• Do you close the loop of showing me how my giving directly impacts your organization and does your mission align with my worldview? 

Gone are the days of baby boomers and Silent Generation writing checks to the nonprofit’s non-designated general operating funds. Younger generations require more personal and causal connections for their philanthropy. 

This decline in broad participation has led to the marginalization of giving. Ironically enough, the most prominent example of how this shift is taking hold is Giving Tuesday, the well-intentioned global movement of giving back across communities following the rush of Black Friday and Cyber Monday. 

While there’s nothing inherently wrong with focusing our attention on a day that revolves around giving, we should consider the following questions:

• Why is a day hyper-focused on giving required? Do donors really need to be reminded about their value to a cause?
• Why did this day become a key strategy for closing the gap toward annual funding goals?
• What would happen if this day didn’t exist?

To answer these questions, we have to go deeper into why Giving Tuesday is simply ineffective for nonprofits and how organizations can best position themselves to encourage donors to give year-round.

A Unique Opportunity for Nonprofits

There are social, economic and political forces that influence rates of giving and popular causes these days. But for all its good intentions, Giving Tuesday — which makes giving an exceptional event — underscores the retreat of charitable giving from something that was a regular ingredient of social life to something infrequent, a sporadic interruption of ordinary life. 

Whatever the contributing factors are — and there are many — they don’t entirely displace the key role nonprofits are poised to play in mitigating if not reversing the decline in giving at a wider, societal level. With all the knowledge, tools and technologies available for fundraising today, nonprofits must ask themselves what more they could be doing or do better, to help ignite a culture of generosity. 

At stake is an extraordinary opportunity to reposition giving in the minds of ordinary donors from an annual, one-day, exceptional occurrence to something they embrace as part of their day-to-day lives.

From Giving Tuesday to Giving Year-Round

Turning every day into a giving day requires that nonprofits break a long-standing pattern in fundraising. 

First, the nonprofit business model has been centered for too long now on meeting annual fundraising targets. Maintaining that posture has led nonprofits to view donors as proxies for transactions — at the expense of donor relationship-building. By reorienting themselves so that they are interacting with donors as real people — and reaching out to them throughout the year in consistent, personalized, relevant ways — nonprofits can leave each donor feeling acknowledged and recognized as an advocate and a catalyst for change.

The more progress nonprofits make in this direction — from being transaction-driven to relationship-minded — the more donors will come to see their advocacy as a regular, perennial feature of their lives. Giving becomes interwoven with other aspects of their lives that they deem valuable and worth sustaining.